CLINICAL SCIENCES: Visual Acuity Outcomes Among Sham vs No-Treatment Controls From Randomized Trials Hawkins, B. S., Bressler, N. M., Reynolds, S. M. Mon, 08 Jun 2009 00:00:00 -0000
Objective To compare 2-year visual acuity outcomes between similar participants assigned to sham and no-treatment control arms in randomized clinical trials.
Methods We retrospectively matched sham controls from 2 randomized trials to no-treatment controls (no sham or placebo) from 3 trials on 8 baseline prognostic criteria (full matches) or on 4 to 7 criteria (partial matches). Outcomes were compared using data from those who had 2-year visual acuity measurements and also using the last observation carried forward method to impute missing 2-year measurements.
Results A full match to a no-treatment control was identified for 72 of 321 sham controls (22%); a partial match was identified for another 93 sham controls (29%). Among the fully matched pairs, no important difference in 2-year visual acuity outcomes was observed. However, 2-year outcomes differed somewhat between sham and no-treatment controls within the partially matched pairs.
Conclusions Findings from fully matched pairs suggest that sham treatment to mask participants in clinical trials may be unnecessary when visual acuity is the outcome of interest. However, findings from the partially matched pairs do not fully support this conclusion. This analysis challenges the necessity for sham (placebo) controls in randomized clinical trials in ophthalmology when visual acuity is the primary outcome of interest.
FROM THE ARCHIVES OF THE ARCHIVES: 140 Years Ago . . . Mon, 08 Jun 2009 00:00:00 -0000
Eyedocfinder.com - An interactive referral service for consumers seeking eyecare professionals in the United States.
EyeDocShop.com - Find an ophthalmologist or optometrist in your area.
Meta Description: [ Find an ophthalmologist for accurate diagnosis and treatment of vision disorders. ]
EyePlastics.com - Allows patients to locate clinical information about their oculoplastic diagnosis and find a fellowship trained surgeon.
Meta Description: [ Eyelid surgery, cosmetic surgery ]
Lasik1.com - Offers a description of Lasik and a limited directory of clinics that offer the surgery.
Meta Description: [ LASIK Laser Eye Surgery - PRK and LASIK Today - Independent and objective, comprehensive information about LASIK and PRK Laser Eye Surgery. Worldwide directory of LASIK eye surgeons, excimer laser manufacturers, LASIK patient financing companies and other medical professionals. ]
Public Records Directory | Search the Public Records